True Crime Episodes

In this episode of Scary Savannah and Beyond, Brett and Crystal dive into the chilling legend of the Greenbrier Ghost, the only case in U.S. history where a ghost’s testimony helped convict a murderer. Set in 1897 West Virginia, the story follows the tragic death of Elva Zona Heaster, whose spirit allegedly returned to reveal the truth about her husband’s violent crime—ultimately leading to his conviction. Along the way, the hosts explore Appalachian folklore, eerie “haint” tales, graveyard dogs...

In this gripping true crime episode, Crystal and Brett dive into the chilling case of the 1982 Chicago Tylenol murders—a nationwide panic that changed the way we package and trust over-the-counter medicine forever. Explore the tragic string of cyanide-laced Tylenol deaths, the ensuing public hysteria, and the intense manhunt for the elusive killer. With dark humor, historical context, and a deep dive into suspects like James William Lewis and Roger Arnold, the hosts unpack one of the most infamo...

This week we dive into the mysterious unsolved fire at an amusement park on the Syndey Harbor, Luna Park. What caused the fire on the ride “The Ghost Train”, taking the lives of seven people. Was it arson? Or faulty wiring? Or a discarded...

This week we dive into the mysterious disappearance of Jimmy Hoffa, and its possible ties to Savannah. Find out if Crystal can make it as a 1950s housewife. On What We’re Watching we talk about the 2024 disaster of a game that’s supposed to be a...

This week we’re going really dark with a story from the early 20th century exploring Italy’s first female serial killer. Trigger Warning - Listener Discretion advised. On What We’re Watching we talk about the 2024 show “Death and Other...

This week we’re talking about a true crime story out of Charlotte, North Carolina. The Loomis Fargo heist was one of the biggest robberies in the history of the nation, with around $17 million dollars being stolen in total. Another interesting fact...

This week Crystal’s going to be talking about a really interesting true crime case involving none other than Santa Claus! It seems back in 1927 someone thought it would be a good idea to dress up as Santa Claus and try to rob a bank. Spoiler alert -...

In this week’s episode we talk about the story of a young African American woman who was put to death for the murder of her 11 month old son in Dallas, North Carolina. She holds the distinction of being the last woman hanged in North Carolina, in...

In this bonus episode we talk about the guilty verdict that was handed down on March 2, 2023 in the case of the state of SC vs Richard Alexander Murdaugh. The jury of 7 men and 5 women found 54 year old disbarred attorney Alex Murdaugh guilty on all...

In today’s Bonus Episode we give the latest updates from the Alex Murdaugh trial that just finished its second week. A recorded interview that was conducted by SLED with Alex was played for the courtroom. The prosecution is claiming that Alex...

In today’s Bonus Episode we discuss the opening statements from the state and the defense in the Alex Murdaugh trial. The state lays out the case against the disbarred South Carolina attorney and Dick Harpootlian attempts to humanize his client and...

We share an update on the Alex Murdaugh case, new updates that can possibly change the trajectory of the case. Many think this could be the next OJ Simpson trial, and it's happening in our own backyard. We will keep you update as this case progresses....

In this week’s episode we talk about a true crime case from our home, Tybee Island. Tybee Island is just a short drive outside of Savannah, Georgia. In 2002 Joni O’Shaughnessy died under mysterious circumstances in her bathtub on Miller Ave. ...

In this week’s episode we’re doing something a little different - we’re talking about a current events true crime case. The case of Alex Murdaugh is both mysterious and engaging. Learn more about this case that’s happening in our backyard....

In this week’s episode we’re talking about one of the great myths of the season - Halloween candy! Plus we talk about the “true” tale of Jack of the Lantern, where we get Jack-O-Lanterns from!   Plus a visit from Big Government and Big...

In this week’s episode we’re talking about Las Vegas! We just took a trip there and had a great time - and we learned about Lake Mead. Lake Mead hides a lot of mysteries, and it’s been tragically dropping in level rapidly, threatening the water...

In this week’s episode we talk about what is called the most diabolical crime in Savannah’s history, the triple murders that happened at the Gribble House. On What We’re Watching, we review the 2016 Horror/Drama show “Slasher: Season 1” And...

In this week’s episode we talk about the haunted Bradley Lock & Key. Located in downtown Savannah, this staple of the historic district has been serving the area since 1883, and is one of the oldest locksmith shops in the country. But like...

In this week’s episode we talk about the true crime story involving an heir of the Golden Brewing company (also known as Coors). On February 9, 1960, while on his way to work, he was assaulted and murdered in an attempted kidnapping plot for ransom....

In this week’s episode we’ll be talking about one of the most twisted serial killers of all time, the king of the Chicago murder castle, H.H. Holmes. On What We’re Watching, we review the 2016 slasher horror comedy film, “Prevenge.” And on...

In this week’s episode we’ll be talking about the infamous case of the Bloody Benders. This family committed atrocities in the late 1800’s in Kansas. We then move over to Charleston, SC to talk about possibly the first female serial killer,...

In this week’s episode we’re going to be talking about a relatively unknown true crime case of Jesse McKethan, also known as the Butcher of Savannah. We also review the horror movie Ghost Killers Versus Bloody Mary. And on Layla and Coffee talk,...

In this week’s episode we’re going to be talking about the creepy pasta phenomenon known as Slenderman and the true crime story associated with it. We also give an update on the Forsyth Park Inn, we stayed on Valentine’s Day, and got a tour from...

In this episode we take an in-depth look at the mysterious murder cases surronding millionaire Robert Durst, and one of his victims with Las Vegas ties. We also talk about Crystal’s experience with Penn & Teller in Vegas, and discuss how dogs keep...