True Crime Episodes

Episodes that feature True Crime stories
Jan. 30, 2023

Tybee Island Police Blotter - Crazy Crimes on the Island Outside Sava…

We are starting a new bonus segment that we will be issuing sometimes on our off weeks. Beautiful Tybee Island is a barrier island right beside Savannah, and we're known as a party town. Every week the Tybee Island police …

Episode page
Jan. 26, 2023

Alex Murdaugh - Case Update 1/25/23

In today’s Bonus Episode we discuss the opening statements from the state and the defense in the Alex Murdaugh trial. The state lays out the case against the disbarred South Carolina attorney and Dick Harpootlian attempts to humanize his client …

Episode page
Jan. 20, 2023

Alex Murdaugh - Case Update 1/20/23

We share an update on the Alex Murdaugh case, new updates that can possibly change the trajectory of the case. Many think this could be the next OJ Simpson trial, and it's happening in our own backyard. We will keep …

Episode page
Jan. 9, 2023

Ep. 60: Murder or Accident on Tybee? The Case of Joni O'Shaughnessy

In this week’s episode we talk about a true crime case from our home, Tybee Island. Tybee Island is just a short drive outside of Savannah, Georgia. In 2002 Joni O’Shaughnessy died under mysterious circumstances in her bathtub on Miller …

Episode page
Dec. 5, 2022

Ep. 56: Alex Murdaugh: A Dark True Crime Case In The Low Country

In this week’s episode we’re doing something a little different - we’re talking about a current events true crime case. The case of Alex Murdaugh is both mysterious and engaging. Learn more about this case that’s happening in our backyard....

Episode page
Oct. 31, 2022

Ep. 51: Halloween Candy Myths and the “True” Tale of Jack of the Lant…

In this week’s episode we’re talking about one of the great myths of the season - Halloween candy! Plus we talk about the “true” tale of Jack of the Lantern, where we get Jack-O-Lanterns from! Plus a visit from Big …

Episode page
Oct. 3, 2022

Ep. 47: Las Vegas: The Bodies of Lake Mead, Start of the Vegas Mafia

In this week’s episode we’re talking about Las Vegas! We just took a trip there and had a great time - and we learned about Lake Mead. Lake Mead hides a lot of mysteries, and it’s been tragically dropping in …

Episode page
Aug. 1, 2022

Ep. 39: The Most Diabolical Crime in Savannah History, the Gribble Ho…

In this week’s episode we talk about what is called the most diabolical crime in Savannah’s history, the triple murders that happened at the Gribble House. On What We’re Watching, we review the 2016 Horror/Drama show “Slasher: Season 1” And...

Episode page
June 20, 2022

Ep. 33: Savannah's Haunted Bradley Lock & Key, The I-95 Killer

In this week’s episode we talk about the haunted Bradley Lock & Key. Located in downtown Savannah, this staple of the historic district has been serving the area since 1883, and is one of the oldest locksmith shops in the …

Episode page
June 13, 2022

Ep. 32: The Botched Kidnapping and Murder of Adolph Coors III

In this week’s episode we talk about the true crime story involving an heir of the Golden Brewing company (also known as Coors). On February 9, 1960, while on his way to work, he was assaulted and murdered in an …

Episode page
May 2, 2022

Ep.26: The Twisted Tale of H.H. Holmes

In this week’s episode we’ll be talking about one of the most twisted serial killers of all time, the king of the Chicago murder castle, H.H. Holmes. On What We’re Watching, we review the 2016 slasher horror comedy film, “Prevenge.” …

Episode page
April 11, 2022

Ep.23: The Bloody Benders, Lavinia Fisher

In this week’s episode we’ll be talking about the infamous case of the Bloody Benders. This family committed atrocities in the late 1800’s in Kansas. We then move over to Charleston, SC to talk about possibly the first female serial …

Episode page
Feb. 28, 2022

Ep.17: The Butcher of Savannah

In this week’s episode we’re going to be talking about a relatively unknown true crime case of Jesse McKethan, also known as the Butcher of Savannah. We also review the horror movie Ghost Killers Versus Bloody Mary. And on Layla …

Episode page
Feb. 21, 2022

Ep.16: Slenderman and the true crime stabbing case involving Anissa W…

In this week’s episode we’re going to be talking about the creepy pasta phenomenon known as Slenderman and the true crime story associated with it. We also give an update on the Forsyth Park Inn, we stayed on Valentine’s Day, …

Episode page
Jan. 31, 2022

Ep.13: The Creepy Case of Millionaire Robert Durst, Las Vegas, Dogs

In this episode we take an in-depth look at the mysterious murder cases surronding millionaire Robert Durst, and one of his victims with Las Vegas ties. We also talk about Crystal’s experience with Penn & Teller in Vegas, and discuss …

Episode page